The 9 Best Seafood Restaurants Naples Florida with Hidden Gems Included


Welcome to my unofficial guide to the Best Seafood Restaurants in Naples Florida!

After spending the last month in Naples Florida with my boyfriend we decided to find the very best restaurants that serve seafood and we went above and beyond the call of duty to test them out; meanwhile we probably lost some weight on this food, maybe we can come up with a new fad diet…


Finding the perfect seafood restaurant for your tastes comes down to three things, your willingness to drive, atmosphere and cuisine. As soon as you know this it will be easy to find the one that’s the right one.

You see we are on the road constantly with my boyfriend because we’re wandering through the US. We fell in love with each other and the lifestyle as well. Plus we are blogging about our experience to help you decide what place to hit first.

I’m ranking the top 9 seafood restaurants in Naples FL on food freshness, tastiness, selection and of course price.

No matter which restaurant you pick from below it’s a guaranteed winner. These were all vetted by us. So what are you waiting for?

Let me see them already!



#1 The Turtle Club Restaurant – Best Overall Seafood Restaurants Naples Florida

To try out the best seafood place lead us to the Turtle Club.

As we sat down at the table, I couldn’t help but take in the wonderful view. The sun was setting behind the beach, painting the sky with a beautiful orange hue. I looked out at the waves crashing against the shore, and I felt myself begin to relax.

We had planned this dinner for a long time now. Also we had heard so many good things about the Turtle Club, and finally we were able to experience it for me. We were not disappointed.

The food was amazing. We could taste the freshness of the seafood in every bite. The service was outstanding. Our waiter was so attentive and helpful. He made sure we had everything we needed and answered all of our questions.

Here’s why it’s #1 on my list:

  • The Turtle Club has a great location with beautiful views
  • The service is professional and the staff are pleasant
  • The seafood is excellent and will satisfy any seafood lover
  • The Keylime pie is delicious and a perfect way to finish a meal
  • If you want to dine on the patio outside, make sure you make reservations.

Address: 9225 Gulf Shore Drive At the Vanderbilt Beach Resort, Naples Florida

#2 Truluck’s Ocean’s Finest Seafood & Crab – Best Fresh Seafood In Naples Florida

We just love seafood, so we were thrilled when we discovered that Naples, Florida is home to some of the best seafood restaurants in the country. You can’t go wrong with Truluck’s Ocean’s Finest Seafood & Crab.

The restaurant put us in a lovely back booth that was ideal for us. The wine service we received and the assistant were both extremely professional and courteous when it came to choosing beverages. There’s also a great selection of wines available. They also have a gluten-free menu, as well as other options.

Many people choose salads for the first course, but we wanted something special like the Stone crab claws (awesome and enormous) and shrimp cocktail – delicious and ceviche. The main course options were varied and everyone was able to find something they loved. I personally enjoyed the fresh fish of the day, which was cooked to perfection.

Yummy, tasty and definitely worth it.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The restaurant is beautifully presented
  • The service is excellent
  • There’s a great selection of wines available
  • They also have a gluten-free menu
  • We also served Stone crab claws (awesome and enormous) and shrimp cocktail – delicious and ceviche

Address: 698 4th Ave S, Naples Florida

#3 USS Nemo – Best Seafood Restaurants Near Me

We were walking through the busy streets of Naples when I saw a sign for USS Nemo. We decided to check it out, and I’m so glad we did.

The food was amazing, and there was a lot of it to choose from. It was the perfect place for a date or a small party. The only downside was that it was a bit noisy.

The food had a wide range of fish dishes with Asian accents, and the kitchen was full of skill. The majority of mains cost around $20 to $30, come with starch and/or vegetable, and are very delicious.

Grilled swordfish, ginger steamed fish (snapper or seabass), scallops, yellowtail snapper, miso broiled sea bass, and grilled kampachi were all excellent.

As an alternative, there were a few meat mains for people who don’t enjoy fish. We generally began by splitting a green salad (about $10), sometimes the calamari, and adding another vegetable to the table (great veggies!!).

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The food is delicious with a wide variety of fish dishes to choose from
  • The space is comfortable and great for small groups
  • The service is excellent with great attention to detail
  • The atmosphere is perfect for a casual night out with friends or a romantic dinner for two.
  • The prices are affordable

Address: 3745 Tamiami Trl N, Naples Florida

#4 Captain & Krewe – Best Casual Seafood Restaurants Naples Florida

It was a hot, humid day in Naples and we were looking for a place to cool down and enjoy some fresh seafood. We had heard great things about Captain & Krewe, so we decided to check it out.

As soon as we walked in, I could smell the salty ocean air and the delicious seafood cooking in the kitchen. We were greeted by a friendly bartender who offered us an iced cold beer. They read our minds.

We decided to try the lobster roll and it did not disappoint. The lobster was fresh and the brioche bun was perfectly fluffy. The tomato and avocado added a nice touch of sweetness and creaminess.

The key lime pie was also incredible. It was tart, sweet, and had the perfect amount of lime flavor.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The seafood is always fresh
  • The food is delicious
  • The service is excellent
  • It’s a unique, half-restaurant, half-fish market
  • You must try the lobster roll it is outstanding
  • The key lime pie is superior to anything we previously had
  • The atmosphere is cozy and inviting

Address: 629 8th St S, Naples Florida

#5 MR. Big Fish – Best Waterfront Seafood Restaurant Naples Florida

I was so excited to try out Mr. Big Fish after reading such great reviews.

Typically seafood isn’t my first pick for a meal. Boy, am I glad that I did! The fish was cooked to perfection and the sides were delicious. Egzon, our waiter, was so attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. He helped us pick out the perfect wine to pair with our meal.

This was easily one of the best dining experiences we ever had.

Here’s why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The restaurant has fresh seafood options
  • The food is well prepared and nicely served
  • The prices are reasonable
  • The restaurant is located in a strip mall, which may be deceiving, but the food is great
  • The waiter was wonderful and offered great menu suggestions
  • The wine and food were both first-rate

Address: 754 Neapolitan Way, Naples Florida

#6 T-Michaels Steak and Lobster

Next on your list was T-Michaels Steak and Lobster, a great place for dinner.

As we walked into the restaurant, I could smell the delicious seafood that was being cooked. I couldn’t wait to taste it! We were greeted by a friendly server who showed me to my table. I was surprised to see that the restaurant was so full on a Tuesday night.

We took a seat and began to look at the menu. I was having a hard time deciding what to order because everything sounded so good! I finally decided on the Seafood Trio, and I was not disappointed. The food was cooked perfectly, and the flavors were amazing.

We were also very impressed with the service. My server was attentive without being overwhelming, and she made sure that I had everything I wanted.

After the glorious meal we were left with the feeling of being completely satisfied.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The seafood is cooked to perfection
  • The cuisine is excellent
  • Their beverages are not disappointing
  • The freshness and deliciousness of the seafood are superb
  • The servers are professional and attentive without being overwhelming
  • The atmosphere is pleasant and perfect for a special evening out.

Address: 4050 Gulf Shore Blvd N The Village on Venetian Bay, Naples Florida

#7 Gulf Coast Grouper & Chips

During vacation we were continuing our quest to find good seafood restaurants. I had asked a few people where they would recommend and they all said the same thing: Gulf Coast Grouper & Chips.

I wasn’t sure what to expect but when I got there, the atmosphere was great. The restaurant was small but it was very cozy. We sat down and looked at the menu. Everything sounded amazing but we decided to go with the fried grouper sandwich and key lime pie.

The food was incredible. The grouper was cooked perfectly and the key lime pie was one of the best I’ve ever had. The service was also great. Our waitress was very friendly and efficient.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The Gulf Coast Grouper & Chips is a great place to eat seafood because the grouper is caught daily by hand using traditional methods such as line-caught cod or hook-and-line fishing for black sea bass (blackfish).
  • The grouper is one of the best in Naples, and the key lime pie is delicious.
  • The beer is cold and served in a chilled pint glass.
  • Excellent seafood outside of the crowds

Address: 338 Tamiami Trl N, Naples Florida

#8 Swan River Seafood Restaurant

A few of my friends stopped by while we were vacationing in Naples FL. So that only means one thing:

It was a girls’ night out and we were all looking forward to getting dressed up and going out to eat. We had all heard wonderful things about Swan River Seafood Restaurant, so we made reservations and headed over there.

The moment we walked in, we were enchanted by the nautical decor and setting. We ordered martinis and started looking at the menu.

The clam chowder and Thai sweet chili calamari were both excellent. The chowder was packed with clams and had a great flavor profile.

The calamari was also very tasty and we all agreed that it was some of the best we’d ever had. We were full after our meal, but we couldn’t resist ordering the coconut carrot cake to go. It was absolutely delicious and we all had a great time.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The Swan River Seafood Restaurant has a nautical bar and decor that is appealing and amusing.
  • The staff are excellent and provide great service.
  • The drinks are delicious and have great martinis.
  • The seafood meals are excellent and full of flavor.
  • The pricing is very reasonable.
  • It is definitely worth a detour from the main street

Address: 3741 Tamiami Trl N, Naples Florida

#9 The Claw Bar

We arrived at The Claw Bar and I was instantly wowed by the beautiful ambiance and atmosphere. We could see that this was going to be an amazing old-school music and dancing experience.

We walked up to the raw bar and saw the colossal jumbo crab legs. They were so big that they looked like they were ready for us in bite-size pieces, so we could eat them right away.

The filet was fantastic, as well as the raw cauliflower salad, the delicious cornbread and the lovely chef’s vegetable soup between courses.

I was unable to even consider dessert because I had already eaten enough at this sensational restaurant. It was an amazing dining experience of international caliber.

This is why you have to try this restaurant:

  • The Claw Bar has a beautiful ambiance and atmosphere
  • For amazing old school music and dancing, don’t miss the London Club on the top floor
  • The raw bar appears to have been built by a Hollywood production crew
  • The seafood offerings are outstanding
  • All of it was excellent, including the raw cauliflower salad, delicious cornbread, and a lovely chef’s vegetable soup between courses
  • Service is exceptional and the dining experience is of international caliber.

Address: 221 9th St S, Naples, FL 34102

Which are the best Seafood Restaurants Marco Island?

The best Seafood Restaurants Marco Island are:

  • Pinchers
  • Lee Be Fish
  • Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House
  • The Oyster Society
  • Snook Inn

Which are the Best Restaurants Naples Florida?

The Best Restaurants Naples Florida are:

  • Campiello
  • USS Nemo Restaurant
  • The French Brasserie Rustique
  • Riverwalk at Tin City
  • BiCE Ristorante
  • Osteria Tulia
  • Truluck’s Ocean’s Finest Seafood and Crab

Conclusions on the Best Seafood Restaurants Naples Florida

I had so much seafood during this quest that it’s probably more than I had in the past 2 years. It was all worth it. Not only we had a great experience and found a bunch of new restaurants but we are able to share it with you.

As promised we left no stone unturned. These are the best restaurants for seafood in Naples FL.

Maybe you can help me out? If you liked this article and you learned some valuable things please share it because it helps us a lot. Thank You!

Frequently Asked Questions:

What seafood is Naples Florida known for?

Naples Florida is famous for its oysters “Turtlefeller,” Sea Harvest, and the Roasted Lobster Tail and Petite filet. You can’t leave without trying the huge crab legs.

What city has the best seafood in Florida?

Here are the best seafood restaurants in Florida by city:

  • CVI.CHE 105, Miami
  • Truluck’s Ocean’s Finest Seafood & Crab, Miami
  • Eddie V’s Prime Seafood, Orlando
  • Deep Blu Seafood Grille, Orlando
  • Oystercatchers, Tampa
  • Rusty Pelican, Tampa
  • The Turtle Club Restaurant, Naples FL
  • USS Nemo, Naples FL
  • Julington Creek Fish Camp, Jacksonville
  • JL Trent’s Seafood and Grill, Jacksonville

What is the oldest restaurant in Naples Florida?

The oldest running restaurant in Naples Florida is Kelly’s Fish House Dining Room established in 1952. It’s located at 1302 Fifth Avenue S. (US 41 E).

How many restaurants does Naples Florida have?

Naples Florida has more than 700 restaurants with many different meals and choices.

Similar Posts